Surface pro 2 or yoga 2/think-pad yoga?

Ryan5508

Limp Gawd
Joined
Mar 6, 2010
Messages
211
Maybe someone with experience with the yogas or surface pro can give me some helpful recommendations.

I currently have an alienware M17x r3 but I hate traveling (vacations/flights) with it. I cant fit it into my camera bag and need to travel with two bags then.

I'm basically down to the think-pad yoga, yoga 2, or surface pro 2. I don't really game on the m17x anymore so I'm stuck at whether to keep it and travel with a surface 2. Or sell it and get one of the yogas. I like the idea of a tablet for being stuck in an airplane seat, but do those with these find the tablet mode worth it? Or do you end up just using it as a laptop 24/7? or vice versa where you feel a surface would of been a better purchase?

I have spent a limited time with the surface but zero with the yogas.
 

BHenry

Limp Gawd
Joined
Oct 8, 2008
Messages
390
While not a review, it gives you some impressions about the Yoga 2:
http://www.hanselman.com/blog/LivingAHighDPIDesktopLifestyleCanBePainful.aspx

I have an original Surface (non-Pro) and while I really like it, if you are going for the Pro model you'll want either a type or touch cover plus a mouse unless you love track pads. I was looking at a 256 GB Surface Pro 2 vs the Yoga 2 myself and the Yoga won out because of the nice keyboard, lesser cost, and a higher screen resolution.
 

Ryan5508

Limp Gawd
Joined
Mar 6, 2010
Messages
211
I think thats why as of recently I started looking at the Thinkpad yoga more. 1080p still seem just to work better atm. Especially on a smaller screen like these.

For some back story info-
I have tried using an Asus transformer in the past when I traveled but always ended up wanting access to windows apps. Example light room to check out some pictures we took during the day. I already have a note 2 and the transformer quickly became worthless to use ever. Thats were I'm torn with these. I don't ever just sit on the couch and use the m17x because of its size/heat/weight. but it would be a nice option to be able to do so. Travel is when I tend to use a laptop the most though. at home it collects dust mainly due to its issues.
 

Ryan5508

Limp Gawd
Joined
Mar 6, 2010
Messages
211
should also add if I wasn't working 72-84 hours a week I would just spend an hour at best buy playing around with these. I'm working straight through until my vacation days.
 

Tarrosion

Weaksauce
Joined
Oct 2, 2007
Messages
110
- Many of the Yoga 2 Pro reviews note that the super high resolution screen can be a pain to use, lots of programs don't place nice with the high density. And the screen eats more battery than a lower resolution screen.
- Many Yoga 2 Pro reviews complain about poor color reproduction and mustardy yellows...maybe a fix is coming for this?
- Thinkpad Yoga is really expensive, but more configurable.
- I recently got the Dell XPS 12 (like it a lot) and find that I use tablet mode all the time. Especially when combined with orientation lock, it's good for cramped spaces/airplanes, reading in bed, reading pdfs in portrait mode, etc.
 

Ryan5508

Limp Gawd
Joined
Mar 6, 2010
Messages
211
went to bestbuy today and picked up a yoga 2 after using both for a bit. I was torn between both even after a hands on. It for me at least, came down to the bigger screen and much higher quality keyboard. The surface keyboard was much more flexible then I had expected. So far colors and scaling on everything have been great on the yoga.

Now I think I need to sell my M17x off after my vacation.
 

Oldie

Mean Old Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Jan 12, 2004
Messages
21,895
In a slightly smaller screen, I've got an HP Revolve that I really like a lot. Decent enough battery and still a great i5 chip with an SSD.
 
Joined
Jun 4, 2012
Messages
671
One thing to note with the yoga is that it does not have the new 802.11ac wifi capabilites with it. I dont know about the thinkpad yoga, but if it was me, i would look at the thinkpad x1 carbon if it was me, it has touch as well and a 1600p screen.

It is under 3 pounds i think, and made out of plastic composites and carbon fiber.
 

Oldie

Mean Old Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Jan 12, 2004
Messages
21,895
Oh, if it would apply to you for any reason, the Yoga does not have a TPM. Found that out the annoying way.
 
Top