kirbyrj
Fully [H]
- Joined
- Feb 1, 2005
- Messages
- 30,582
Well, I haven't use the front ones yet, so I will reserve judgment for now, but I have come to really like the fluidity of the rear indented finger print sensor. I thought it was one of the biggest positive features of Googles phones. Once you get used to it, as you grab your phone from your pocket your finger just homes in on the fingerprint reader, and by the time you have the phone in a visible position, it is already unlocked.
I suspect the front fingerprint sensor could never be that efficient, but again, I will reserve judgment until I actually use one.
Generally my philosophy is that user interfaces should never change, but if they do it should be evolutionary. Think Windows 95 -> Windows 98 -> Windows XP -> Windows Vista -> Windows 7 as a good trend in this regard.
Developers and designers should learn to never change anything about user interfaces that necessitates a change in muscle memory of their users. Once designed, it should remain fixed in perpetuity (so design it well the first time around)
I still use Nova launcher to get a more constant UI on my launcher. Despite having nothing but Pixel phones since the first Pixel came out, I have never once used the Google Assistant or voice commands. (at least not on purpose, I may have accidentally triggered it once or twice) I don't see myself ever desiring to talk to my phone, or use any AI features what so ever.
I also still use the three navigation buttons on the bottom. I refuse to adapt to gestures.
View attachment 562085
I still miss the classic Office menu we haven't seen sine 2003. It's a WAY better design than the stupid ribbon.
Braking user muscle memory and making things new, just for trends or fashion oor for the sake of making things new is the number one cardinal sin of UI design, IMHO.
I have four demands when I buy a new phone (or device of any kind)
1.) No bloat. Let me opt out of and/or uninstall absolutely everything
2.) No cloud or sync of any kind. Never connect to the internet without being manually requested by the user.
3.) No AI features
4.) Don't change the user interface
5.) Make all new features optional, and opt in, never opt out.
6.) No data collection.
And I want my rear fingerprint sensor, damnit!
Lol... Good luck with that. I mean I didn't like the gestures either and now when I go back to a three-button setup I don't like it.
You might as well just sign up for a flip dumb phone at this point.